I
have been planning to do this video and blog post for a while but
hadn't gotten around to it. I decided that the time had to come to
get myself in gear and get this done because I have heard reports
from several people that their Michael's stores are in the process of
discontinuing the Gallery Glass that we all use so much.
So
far I am happy to report that the Michael's I shop at has not started
to discontinue their supply.
The
reason I wanted to do this comparison in the first place was that I
had noticed that there are currently 3 brands of glass paint in my
local craft store and I wanted to know for myself how they compared.
I decided to do this as a video/ blog post because I thought you
might find the process I use to test this kind of thing helpful. Also
hopefully the results will be useful to you also.
The
brands of paint I am testing today are: Gallery Glass, Martha Stewart
crafts, and Deco Art Glass Stain. I kept the test to 2 colors from
each line. Since the 2 colors of Gallery Glass I use the most are
Amber and Clear I was hoping to test those. However, only Gallery
Glass has an Amber. Both of the other brands have an orange and brown
and Amber falls in between those two colors. Since I already had a
brown in the Deco Art brand I chose to try the orange color in Martha
Stewart. The prices of the 3 brands were comparable at my store with
Gallery Glass at $2.79, Deco Art at $2.99 and the Maths Stewart
didn't have a shelf tag but rang up at $2.44 on sale (30% off regular
price, you can do the math)
I
didn't really like the packaging on the Martha Stewart brand because
it seemed to be overkill. The bottles were both shrink wrapped and
there was a paper/foil seal on the bottle. Also the opening on the
actual bottle is really small as is the opening on the nozzle top.
The
Deco Art just had the paper/foil seal on the actual bottle top and I
think that is sufficient.
If
I remember correctly Gallery Glass just has the shrink wrap not the
paper/foil seal.
As
for the openings of the nozzles on the bottles the Gallery Glass
seems to be the middle sized. The Deco Art is a bit large and I can
see where the product could come out too fast from the bottle. On the
other end of the spectrum the Martha Stewart nozzle is really too
small. I actually had trouble getting the product even out of the
bottle.
To
set up for the test I decided that the bacon and fried eggs that I
made recently would be good tests for the paints. I mentally divided
up a paper plate into 3 areas and put one egg and one slice of bacon
cane in each area. I used some TLS to adhere the clay to the plate so
they will stay in place after baking so even if I manage to drop the
plate I will still know for sure which is which.
After
the clay was baked and cooled I labeled the three sets of clay with
the initials of the product. Any notes you need to keep your info
straight works here. I do the same thing when I am testing color
mixtures of clay but I write down the colors or brands of clay used.
Next
step was to apply the paint to the clay pieces. I used my finger
being sure to clean up between colors/brands with a wet wipe.
Now
we needed to just wait for the paints to dry. I found no information
on the bottles on how much time to expect this to take so I just had
to wait and check back every once in a while.
The
paints all were dry in a short time I'm not sure how long it took
since I had to leave the house to run some errands and all were dry
when I returned.
The
Gallery Glass is definitely the winner in this test. It dries smooth,
the color is just what I need for projects, etc.
|
Gallery Glass sample as applied | | | | |
|
Gallery Glass sample after drying is complete |
The
Martha Stewart, the dried finish on this one is a bit on the grainy
side and I really wish it had a bit more shine. The biggest downfall
though is the lack of an amber color. Also I really dislike the
bottle! This one runs at a distant 2nd to the Gallery
Glass.
|
Martha Stewart as applied |
|
|
Martha Stewart after drying is complete |
|
|
The
Deco Art is really grainy in my opinion when dry, for some uses that
might be a good thing but not for the applications we are testing
today. I do prefer the bottle but because of the texture of the
product once I dry I have to place it last in the ratings.
|
Deco Art as applied |
|
|
Deco Art after drying is complete |
I
hope this was helpful to you, if there are other products you would
like to see me test let me know and I'll see what I can do.
Also
as a side note, I am looking into other sources for Gallery Glass for
all of you. If it does become harder to locate I have a few ideas but
that is in the future.